Skip to main content

Table 2 Classes of modeling assumption constraints (from functional viewpoint)

From: A framework of generating explanation for conceptual understanding based on “semantics of constraints”

 

Subclasses

Subsubclasses

Definition

Examples

MAC

Process consideration constraint (PCC)

Decision about what kind of physical processes are considered in modeling

Process selection constraint (PS)

Specifies what kind of processes in a physical system are considered/ignored

- Consider (rel-friction(b l, p l)) PA

- Ignore the change of form/mass of objects which collided PO

- Consider the heat exchange between two objects (T H > T L) PR

Out-sourcing constraint (OS)

Ignores a physical process by putting it out of the system and regarding its effect as a boundary condition

- An outer tank which supplies water infinitely PR

- An outer power supply which always supplies 5 V PR

- Initial velocity v(0) = v 0 PR

 

Black-boxing constraint (BB)

Ignores a physical process by putting it in a black box and regarding its effect as a boundary condition

- Consider two parallel-connected springs/resistors as they are or a compound one PO

- Consider two blocks in contact moving with internal force as one PO/CR

Physical world constraint (PWC)

Necessity for maintaining the fundamental law of the physical world

Maintains the fundamental law of the physical world

- Rigid objects never overlap CR

- Mass >0, μ > 0, 0 ≤ e ≤ 1 PR

- g = 9.8 [m/s/s], gas constant = 8.3 [J/K mol] PR

 

Process simplifying constraint (PFC)

Convenience for mathematical calculation with the model

Substitutes the simplified process for a complicated (original) process

- Consider the range within which a resistance’s voltage and current are proportional PR

- Consider the behavior of a pendulum with small amplitude as simple harmonic oscillation PR